Why Did I do a video on Islam and The Temple Mount

I chose recently to make a new video (See bottom of the page) about Islam and the Temple Mount and answer the question:

“Why is the Temple Mount (Haram El Sharif) important to Muslims?” A day before I made the video the following thing happened:

I was standing in Synagogue, a guy turns around to me and asks “What do you do?”. I told him that I am a tour guide.

He says: “I hope that you’re not one of those guides who tell people that Muslims have anything here”. He went on to say that guides who do this are in fact “sellouts”, that the Temple Mount is only holy for us Jews and everyone else can get lost.

The truth is, the Temple Mount is the only place in the world that is truly holy for Jews, the place the first Temple stood, the place the Second Temple stood. Every time a Jew turns and prays it is to Jerusalem and the site of the Temple. Every Orthodox Jew prays 3 times a day for the rebuilding of the Temple. However, that is far from the “whole story” and far from what a decent tour guide who studies the texts should tell you in its entirety.

People come to Jerusalem and hire a guide to hear from an educated person the story and history of Jerusalem. If you were introducing the history of Jerusalem it would be irresponsible and really silly to leave out the various periods of Muslim rule; in total over 1000 years of rule. Did this man honestly expect me to leap from “The Romans destroyed the Temple in the year 70…. now we have a Jewish State”? Islam is a part of the history of Jerusalem, it takes a shockingly insecure person to try and ignore their history.

I accept that the Temple Mount has become entwined in the conflict between Israel and Palestine. May Israelis and Palestinians have lost family and friends. It becomes very difficult to stick to the facts or to divide cold history from our feelings and desires to protect ourselves, not to sell out, to be true to ourselves and be proud Israelis.

As a religious Jew, I have no problem with other religions finding Jerusalem to be important. I actually think that this is how a future Messianic Age will come about. As Isaiah wrote:

“For My house will be a House of Prayer for All Nations”

כי ביתי בית תפילה יקרא לכח העמים

Isaiah 56:7

Jerusalem is the center of my world and it should be the center of the world for all nations, not divide us in arguments about whose buildings should be destroyed, rather Jerusalem should unite us to better our global condition.

New Media, New Forums, New Challenges and new ways to show your support

I’ve been very busy.

As you well might imagine my business took a nose dive due to the International COVID-19 crisis. All the planes from abroad were cancelled and any form of socializing was prohibited for a short space of time. My regular job at the Western Wall Tunnels ended. All tours were cancelled for the foreseeable future.

I did not stop, I did not give up and still today I am touring, educating and learning.

As soon as I could, I started work at an archeological site, not as a glamorous educator, but as a worker shifting buckets of sand in the hot sun. This I call my daily Archeo-Zumba!

 

I started this Youtube channel:

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcQWuD6k-Xruf1H1dVqUyUw

 

I recorded a new podcast and am recording another one right now!

And I haven’t finished yet…

I started a subreddit too!

r/HistoryofJudaismcast Lounge from HistoryofJudaismcast

Do you want to help?

Then Please Comment!

Like and Share my work!

If you really want to help physically, I need to be able to sustain these media, improve my hardware, pay bills (of course!) and drink the occaisional coffee!

Building the Temple – a work in progress

A work in Progress

A visit to the Roman Engineering exhibit at the Davidson Center

It is believed that the Herodion Temple Mount took much longer to build than Herod actually lived for. Consider how long it must have took to even build the machinery and work out the engineering to build the entire massive structure.

The Temple Mount had 140,000 square meters surface area. The Western Wall is 488 meters in length alone. The largest stone is well over 280 tonnes (some say 570 tonnes). According to the Christian Scripture it took more than 46 years to build (John 2:20).

It is highly likely that , not unlike this blog, there were many starts and stops!

Stay tuned for more interesting and entertaining blogs, podcasts and videos!

 

Spotlight on Nature: Safari Map Update

I’m getting ready for the spring migration and my new Suburban safari (Coming Soon!). So I’ve been checking out the area of Jerusalem around the ‘Old train Station’, Yemin Moshe and the Walls of the Old City. Today I saw some fantastic little birds: Graceful Prinias, Chiffchaffs, and what I think is a Masked Shrike. See the Map below for more information.

Watch this Space for more news.

Chanukah Old City Scavenger Hunt

6496_845429570226_2500361_48415234_2836899_n

Looking for something fun to do with the kids?

I am running a Jewish Quarter Scavenger hunt for all the family!

Where? Meeting Point Jaffa Gate, next to the tourist information center look for a guy holding a placard.

When? Thursday November 10th, 10:00 am – 1pm

How Much? 20 shekels per child, accompanying adults go free. (Unaccompanied adults do not go free)

Mystery Star Prize (edible)

Age Range: 4-7, 8 – 12, 13 – 15. (different tasks will be given to different ages)

Schedule

10:00-10:30 Introduction, formation of teams, rules

10:30-12 scavenger hunt

12-12:30 Sharing our findings

12:30-1 giving out of prizes

The Rules

  1. ALL children must be accompanied by an adult.
  2. We split into groups based on how many people turn up
  3. Lists will be handed out of things you have to acquire, this can mean you physically take that item or you photograph it / bring proof that you found the item.
  4. Upon completion of all the list return with your list to the designated meeting point.
  5. The first group back with a completed list wins.
  6. All adults will be given a map and clearly demarcated boundaries are asked NOT to wander beyond those boundaries for safety reasons.

For more information email: yossisilverman@gmail.com

Spotlight on Nature: Latest Safari Map Update

I’ve been preparing for a new tour and part of this preparation has been mapping the wildlife in the southern suburbs of Jerusalem. My recent astounding sightings have been;

Graceful Prinia (bird)

Eurasian Jays

Kuhl’s Pipistrelle Bat

European Green Toad

Common Gazelle (!)

You can check regular updates on this map:

It was a wonderful experience seeing the gazelle at 5:30 am as the sun rose over the Jerusalem hills.  I’m going to be preparing this tour for the next few months, if your interested in booking me for a tour you can contact me here.

Doves of Peace



Portion of the Week: Vayikra (Leviticus 1:1 – 5:26)


‘ואם מין העוף עולה קרבנו לה”

“והקריב מן התורים ומין בני יונה את קרבנו

“If he is to bring an offering that is to be eaten to the Eternal then he shall bring it from the ‘Torim’ Doves and from the Doves”

This week’s portion fits in very well with the official start of my blog, for it is the official start of a new reading of a book of the Pentateuch; ‘Vayikra’ (Leviticus: the Laws of Priesthood or in Hebrew ‘He Called’). It also contains a very important concept to Jews; Peace.

The quote above is dealing with the laws concerning a person who wishes to offer a bird as an offering to the Eternal one. According to this verse, one can only offer either a Dove or a Rock pigeon. But this is very confusing as any decent bird watcher will instantly tell you; Rock pigeons (the Grand Daddy of our City Pigeons) are a type of Dove.

Why can’t you just say; ‘bring me your Doves !’ or some thing like that?

Also, why Doves? Why can’t you bring chicken? Most good Jews eat chicken (apart from vegetarians, I’m a veggie too, I was upset by the lack of a tofu sacrifice, but that’s a discussion for another time). There is a special significance to this choice of bird.

Most commandments are connected to the reality of the situation of the Children of Israel or the reality that they would face in the Holyland. There are 4 main kinds of Dove that visit Israel, the first was captured on camera by a friend:

The Rock Dove / Pigeon

(picture courtesy of Remi Rauh)

The Collared Dove

The Turtle Dove

Laughing Dove

All of the four fit into the general category ‘Dove’ or ‘Yonah’, the first three, according to scripture, can be categorised as ‘Tor’ in Hebrew, what I have called “‘Torim’ Doves”, the last is part of the Global Category of Doves and Pigeons (see ‘Daat Mikra’ published by Mosad HaRav Kook on this verse who names the first three categories). The first of the three the Rock Dove or Columbia Livia in Latin were commonly used in the ancient Middle East as farmed edible foul. It was very common to have a Columbarium (an underground cave with niches for the housing of doves, now means a mausoleum but originally came from the word ‘Columba’ in Latin meaning Dove) attached to a house as part of the family’s food supply. The picture below was taken in the ruins of a large settlement outside Jerusalem called Maresha, which contains a vast number of underground Columbaria including this massive one which also became a Church and later on a Mosque.

(Columbarium of Beit Guvrin courtesy of Remi Rauh)

It is even suggested that before their domestication it was fairly easy to catch a dove and these are the kind that frequented Israel. So the text is telling us, ‘bring an offering from the ‘Torim’ these are the easiest to find, if not buy a ‘Dove’, it gives us the easiest option first as the more preferable one. This sacrifice is to do with Hesed ; loving-kindness to the person bringing the sacrifice, that it should be a service to the Eternal which is easy to accomplish.

There is a much deeper reason why the Dove is used at all. The Dove is first mentioned in connection with Noah, it is the Dove that heralded the end of the flood and became for eternity the international symbol of Peace. The Great Rabbis said;

‘It is better to be one of the pursuers than one of the pursued and there is none pursued more than the ‘Torim’ Dove and the Dove’ (Babylonian Talmud, Tractate Baba Kama 93 side A, quoting Rabbi Abahu).

This has a dual meaning, firstly it is a message to be essentially a peaceful person (I do n’t think it means get yourself killed, anybody who has tried to trap birds knows that they certainly struggle and if you want proof I’ll happily take you to a Dove ringing at one of the many Bird Survey centres in Israel and prove this to you). Secondly it means to be a person who is at peace with the service of the eternal, it is evident from the many columbarium in the environs of Jerusalem that they were the most common thing to be sacrificed at the temple, the easiest thing for a person to get hold of to serve the Holy One. The message we are given is that we should ourselves be resigned in peace to divine service both with ourselves and with others.